Duplicate or two issuers to one coin [résolu]

4 messages • Vu 57 fois

Ce message a été posté dans le forum anglais.

Ce message a pour but de : demander la modification d'une pièce du catalogue

Statut : Résolu
Votes pour : 0
Votes contre : 0
Grinya Référent
Inscrit le : 8 mai 2017
Messages : 1704
Posté le : 18 sep 2024, 17h21 #
Posté le : #

N#196818

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces382312.html

 

Both attributions are correct

My personal list of scammers from Numista: erniemix, yvain, CassTaylor
État commencé (tdziemia, 18 sep 2024, 21h03)
tdziemia Numista team
Inscrit le : 26 avr 2018
Messages : 4329
Posté le : 18 sep 2024, 21h07 #
Modifié le : 18 sep 2024, 21h09
Posté le : #
Modifié le :

Stephen Album calls these as civic coppers unless the ruler's name is present, and then he places it in the ruling dynasty (Timurid).  I don;t think this one has a ruler's name. 

 

So, one possibility is that we keep the first listing #196818 because (a) it was first, (b) it has a good photo, and (c ) 27 members with the coin, but change the issuer.  Then delete the other one.

Grinya Référent
Inscrit le : 8 mai 2017
Messages : 1704
Posté le : 18 sep 2024, 22h51 #
Modifié le : 19 sep 2024, 16h58
Posté le : #
Modifié le :

Yes, the coin is without ruler name, but it is dated and can be attributed to an exact ruler.

But civic copper shall be more correct I think.

Possibly we need to copy a picture from one to another and leave both of them in the catalogue. I don't know.

 

A ossibility of addition of 2 issuers to one coin may help in such cases

My personal list of scammers from Numista: erniemix, yvain, CassTaylor
État résolu (Jarcek, 29 nov 2024, 13h24)
Jarcek Numista team
Inscrit le : 22 déc 2014
Messages : 16165
Posté le : 29 nov 2024, 13h24 #
Posté le : #

I moved it to Bukhara city and deduplicated.

Catalogue administrator
Répondre
Forum »

» Charte d'utilisation du forum

Le fuseau horaire utilisé est UTC+2:00.
L'heure actuelle est 8h22.