Mintages for 1949 - 1952 Australian Pennies

This discussion concerns this coin series:

N#1561

The stated mintages for some of these coins on the Numista webpage do not agree with the mintages given by SCWC/Numismaster/NGC.

There are three instances of this:

1951 Melbourne: Numista has 45,514,000; the others have 21,240,000

1952 Melbourne: Numista has 21,240,000; the others have 12,408,000

1952 Perth: Numista has 12,408,000; the others have 45,514,000

For these three coins, the same mintages are cited by all four references, they just do not agree upon the date and mint the respective mintages belong.

Does anyone have a definitive Australian reference that can sort this out?

SCWC/Numismaster/NGC are all wrong. A lot of the Australian stuff on Numismaster is a total joke which is where SCWC & NGC probably got there figures from.

The numbers on Numista are correct.

Excerpts from both major Australian catalogues above. Rennicks on the left and McDonalds on the right. 

They both agree and are the same as Numista.

Regards Mike